When the Apostles and Paul Disagree: Ethics, Truth, and the Early Church
When the Apostles and Paul Disagree: Ethics, Truth, and the Early Church One of the most striking aspects of early Christianity is the apparent divergence between the ethical teachings of Jesus and the Twelve apostles, and the later practices and reasoning of Paul. This isn’t just an academic observation; it gets to the core of how early Christianity evolved, and it raises serious questions about moral consistency, authority, and the nature of divine guidance. The Apostolic Ethic: Absolute and Deontological The earliest apostles, following Jesus, operated under a clear moral framework: Obedience and integrity above all: Acts 5:29 says, “We must obey God rather than men,” reflecting the early church’s commitment to act rightly even under pressure. Truthfulness in practice: Peter and John, for example, refused to stop preaching when commanded by authorities (Acts 4:18–20), even at the risk of imprisonment. Simplicity and honesty: The early Jerusalem community shared goods openly and avoi...