Why Covenant Creation Falls Apart: A Detailed Refutation

Why Covenant Creation Falls Apart: A Detailed Refutation Covenant Creation (CC) proposes that Genesis 1 is not about the physical universal origins of the world, but about the inauguration of a covenantal relationship between God and humanity, often symbolized through temple imagery. While it rightly emphasizes covenantal theology and temple patterns in Scripture, CC falls apart when scrutinized closely—especially when it imposes its framework where the text doesn’t support it. Hosea 6:7 Is Not a Foundation A foundational verse for CC is Hosea 6:7, which in some translations says, "Like Adam, they transgressed the covenant." But this verse is a textual variant, and many scholars debate whether “Adam” is a person, a place, or a poetic figure. Building an entire theological system on one ambiguous verse is dangerous. Yes, Adam was in a covenant relationship with God—but we see this through context clues in Genesis 1 and 2, not Hosea 6:7. The shift from “Elohim” in Genesis 1 to ...